Have you ever gone shoe shopping and felt confused about which brand to pick? With so many choices out there, it can be hard to know which shoes will be best for your feet. Today, we’re going to look at two popular shoe brands: New Balance and Columbia. Both make great shoes, but they’re different in many ways.
Contents
- 1 New Balance vs Columbia Shoes
- 2 History of the Brands
- 3 Durability: How Long Will They Last?
- 4 Breathability: Keeping Your Feet Cool
- 5 Cushioning: Protection For Your Feet
- 6 Shoe Fit: Finding Your Perfect Size
- 7 Stability: Keeping Your Feet Steady
- 8 Comfort: How They Feel On Your Feet
- 9 Quality of Materials
- 10 Style Options
- 11 Size Range and Availability
- 12 Weight: How Heavy Are They?
- 13 Flexibility: How They Move with Your Feet
- 14 Water Resistance
- 15 Sole Construction and Traction
- 16 Price Range
- 17 User Reviews and Ratings
- 18 Pros and Cons
- 19 Conclusion
- 20 Frequently Asked Questions
New Balance vs Columbia Shoes
New Balance is known for making athletic shoes that are great for running and sports. Columbia is famous for making outdoor shoes that are good for hiking and camping. In this guide, we’ll compare these two brands to help you decide which one might be right for you. We’ll look at things like comfort, how long they last, and even how they look. Ready to find your perfect pair? Let’s get started!
A Detailed Comparison Table: Finding the Best Choice for Your Comfort and Needs!
| Feature | New Balance | Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Sports, running, everyday wear | Hiking, camping, outdoor activities |
| History | Started 1906 in Boston (athletic focus) | Started 1938 in Oregon (outdoor focus) |
| Durability | Good for everyday use and sports | Excellent for tough outdoor conditions |
| Breathability | Very breathable, especially running shoes | Good, with waterproof options that still breathe |
| Cushioning | Soft, bouncy (Fresh Foam, FuelCell) | Firmer, supportive (Techlite) |
| Fit Options | Many width options (narrow to extra wide) | Fewer width options, roomier toe box |
| Stability | Good for flat surfaces, helps with pronation | Excellent on uneven terrain and trails |
| Comfort | Comfortable right away, soft materials | May need break-in period, then very comfortable |
| Materials | Performance fabrics, some leather/suede | Waterproof materials, tough ripstop fabrics |
| Style | Sporty, trendy, many color options | Rugged, outdoor look, earth tones |
| Weight | Lighter (especially running shoes) | Heavier due to protective features |
| Flexibility | Very flexible, especially in forefoot | Less flexible by design (for protection) |
| Water Resistance | Limited waterproof options | Many fully waterproof models |
| Sole/Traction | Good grip on pavement and flat surfaces | Excellent grip on trails, mud, and rough terrain |
| Price Range | $60-$180 | $70-$200 |
| Size Availability | Extensive kids and adult sizes | More adult focused, fewer kids options |
In summary: New Balance and Columbia serve different niches in footwear. New Balance specializes in athletic sneakers with retro styling and performance technology, popular in urban settings. Columbia focuses on rugged outdoor footwear designed for durability and weather protection, excelling in hiking and trail environments rather than fashion-forward street appeal.
People Also Like:
New Balance vs Geox
History of the Brands
New Balance: Athletic Roots
New Balance started in 1906 in Boston, Massachusetts. That’s over 100 years ago! At first, they made arch supports (special inserts that help your feet feel comfortable). Later, they started making running shoes. New Balance became popular because they made shoes in different widths, which helped people find a better fit.
Columbia: Outdoor Focus
Columbia began in 1938 when a family fled from Nazi Germany to Portland, Oregon. They started as a small hat company. Over time, they grew into a big outdoor clothing and shoe brand. Columbia is known for making gear that keeps people dry and comfortable outdoors. They focus on shoes for hiking, camping, and other outdoor activities.
Durability: How Long Will They Last?
New Balance Durability
New Balance shoes are made to handle everyday wear and sports. They use strong rubber on the bottom of their shoes that can last a long time. The upper parts (where your foot goes in) are usually made with tough materials that don’t tear easily. Many New Balance shoes can last 1-2 years of regular use.
Columbia Durability
Columbia shoes are built to handle tough outdoor conditions. They use special materials and strong construction to make shoes that can handle rocks, mud, and rough trails. The rubber soles are thick and durable. Many Columbia hiking shoes can last for several years if you take care of them properly.
Durability Comparison
Columbia shoes tend to be more durable overall, especially for outdoor use. They’re made to handle tough conditions like muddy trails and rocky paths. New Balance shoes are still quite durable for everyday use and sports, but they might wear out faster if you use them for hiking or on rough terrain.
People Also Like:
New Balance vs Clarks
Breathability: Keeping Your Feet Cool
New Balance Breathability
New Balance uses mesh (material with tiny holes) in many of their shoes. This lets air flow in and out, keeping your feet from getting too sweaty. Their running shoes are especially breathable, which is great for sports or hot days. Some of their casual shoes might not be as breathable, though.
Columbia Breathability
Columbia uses special technologies to make their shoes breathable while still being waterproof. Many of their shoes have mesh panels to let air in. Some use a special material called Omni-Tech that keeps water out but lets sweat escape. This helps keep your feet dry even when hiking or walking in the rain.
Breathability Comparison Table
| Feature | New Balance | Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Summer Use | Excellent – very breathable mesh | Good – breathable but some models prioritize water protection |
| Winter Use | Fair – may let in cold air | Excellent – insulated models available |
| Sweat Management | Very good for athletic activities | Good for hiking and outdoor activities |
| Odor Control | Some models have anti-odor technology | Many models have anti-odor technology |
| Best For | Hot weather sports and running | All-weather outdoor activities |
Cushioning: Protection For Your Feet
New Balance Cushioning
New Balance is known for their cushioning technologies. They use special foams called Fresh Foam and FuelCell that provide soft, bouncy support. Their running shoes often have extra cushioning in the heel and forefoot areas where your foot hits the ground hardest. This helps protect your feet when running or playing sports.
Columbia Cushioning
Columbia uses different types of cushioning designed for walking on uneven ground. Many of their shoes have a technology called Techlite, which is a lightweight midsole that provides cushioning and support. Their hiking shoes often have thicker cushioning that helps protect your feet from rocks and roots on trails.
Cushioning Feel
New Balance cushioning tends to feel softer and bouncier, which is great for running on pavement or gym floors. Columbia cushioning is often firmer and more supportive, which helps when walking on uneven outdoor surfaces. Both provide good comfort, but they feel different under your feet.
Shoe Fit: Finding Your Perfect Size
New Balance Sizing
One of the best things about New Balance is that they offer many width options – narrow, regular, wide, and extra wide. This helps people with different foot shapes find comfortable shoes. New Balance shoes usually run true to size, meaning the size you normally wear will probably fit well.
Columbia Sizing
Columbia shoes tend to have a roomier toe box (the front part where your toes go), which many people like for hiking when your feet might swell. However, they don’t offer as many width options as New Balance. Some Columbia shoes run a bit large, so you might need to try a half-size smaller than usual.
Fit Comparison
If you have wide or narrow feet, New Balance might be better because of their many width options. If you have regular width feet but like extra room in the toe area, Columbia might be more comfortable. Both brands are generally good for people with normal foot shapes.
Stability: Keeping Your Feet Steady
New Balance Stability Features
New Balance makes many shoes with special stability features. Some have firmer material on the inner side to prevent your foot from rolling inward too much (called overpronation). Their stability shoes can help people who have flat feet or ankle issues. Even their regular shoes provide good stability for everyday activities.
Columbia Stability Approach
Columbia designs their shoes with outdoor stability in mind. Their hiking shoes often have wider bases and special outsole patterns that help keep you steady on uneven terrain. Many models have supportive midsoles and sturdy heel cups that cradle your foot to prevent ankle rolls on trails.
Stability Comparison
For everyday stability on flat surfaces, New Balance shoes with stability features work very well. For trail stability and uneven terrain, Columbia shoes are often better designed. Think about where you’ll be using your shoes most to decide which type of stability is more important for you.
People Also Like:
New Balance vs Diadora
Comfort: How They Feel On Your Feet
New Balance Comfort
New Balance shoes are known for being comfortable right out of the box. They use soft materials inside their shoes and have good padding around the ankle and heel. Their cushioning is often plush and feels nice underfoot. Many people who stand all day choose New Balance for comfort.
Columbia Comfort
Columbia focuses on making shoes comfortable for long hikes and outdoor adventures. Their shoes often have good arch support and cushioned insoles. Some hikers find Columbia shoes need a “break-in period” (wearing them for a while until they feel good), but once broken in, they can be very comfortable for all-day wear.
Comfort Features
| Comfort Feature | New Balance | Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Immediate Comfort | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐☆☆ |
| All-Day Wear | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Arch Support | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ |
| Cushioning | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ |
| Ankle Padding | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ |
| Break-in Time | Little to none | May require some |
Quality of Materials
New Balance Materials
New Balance uses high-quality materials in most of their shoes. Their more expensive models often use premium foams and durable synthetic materials. Some lifestyle models even use real suede or leather. Their materials are chosen for performance and comfort in athletic activities.
Columbia Materials
Columbia uses materials designed to handle tough outdoor conditions. They use waterproof leathers, ripstop nylains (fabrics that resist tearing), and rubber compounds that grip well on various surfaces. Many of their shoes include special waterproof membranes and insulation technologies.
Quality Comparison
Both brands use good quality materials, but for different purposes. New Balance materials excel for athletic performance and everyday comfort. Columbia materials are chosen for durability and protection in outdoor environments. Columbia shoes tend to use more weather-resistant materials overall.
Style Options
New Balance Style Range
New Balance offers many style options from sporty running shoes to casual “dad shoes” that have become fashionable. They come in many colors, from bright and bold to simple white or black. New Balance has become popular not just for sports but for everyday fashion too.
Columbia Style Approach
Columbia shoes have a more rugged, outdoor look. They focus less on fashion trends and more on functional design. Their shoes often look ready for adventure with tough outsoles and protective features. They typically come in earth tones and neutral colors like brown, gray, and black.
Style Preference
If you like sporty or trendy casual styles, New Balance might appeal to you more. If you prefer an outdoorsy, adventure-ready look, Columbia will probably match your style better. New Balance offers more fashion-forward options, while Columbia sticks to practical outdoor designs.
People Also Like:
New Balance vs Dunks
Size Range and Availability
New Balance Size Options
New Balance makes shoes in many sizes for kids, teens, and adults. They offer those different width options we mentioned earlier, which is great for people with wide or narrow feet. You can find New Balance shoes in many shoe stores, sporting goods stores, and online shops.
Columbia Size Availability
Columbia focuses more on adult sizes, though they do make some kids’ shoes too. They don’t offer as many width options as New Balance. Columbia shoes are available in outdoor stores, department stores, and online. They might be harder to find in some regular shoe stores.
Size Range
| Feature | New Balance | Columbia |
|---|---|---|
| Kids Sizes | Many options | Limited options |
| Adult Sizes | Full range | Full range |
| Width Options | Multiple (N, B, D, 2E, 4E) | Limited (mostly medium) |
| Store Availability | Widely available | Available in outdoor stores |
| Online Options | Many retailers | Many retailers |
Weight: How Heavy Are They?
New Balance Weight
New Balance shoes vary in weight. Their running shoes are often lightweight, sometimes under 10 ounces per shoe. Their casual and stability shoes can be heavier. The lightweight models are good for sports and activities where speed matters.
Columbia Weight
Columbia shoes tend to be heavier than New Balance shoes. This is because they use thicker materials and more durable construction for outdoor use. A typical Columbia hiking shoe might weigh 12-16 ounces per shoe. The extra weight comes from protective features and sturdy materials.
Weight Comparison
If having lightweight shoes is important to you, especially for running or sports, New Balance typically has lighter options. If you need protective outdoor shoes and don’t mind some extra weight for better durability, Columbia shoes are a good choice.
Flexibility: How They Move with Your Feet
New Balance Flexibility
New Balance running and training shoes are designed to be flexible, especially in the forefoot (front part) where your foot bends when you walk or run. This flexibility helps your foot move naturally during activities. Their casual shoes might be less flexible depending on the model.
Columbia Flexibility
Columbia hiking shoes are usually less flexible than running shoes. This is by design – a stiffer sole helps protect your foot from rocks and provides more stability on uneven ground. However, Columbia does make some trail running shoes that offer more flexibility while still providing protection.
Flexibility Needs
More flexibility is not always better – it depends on what you’re doing. For running on smooth surfaces, the greater flexibility of New Balance shoes works well. For hiking on rocky trails, the controlled flexibility of Columbia shoes provides better protection and support.
Water Resistance
New Balance Water Protection
Most standard New Balance shoes are not waterproof. They do make some models with water-resistant features, but these are not their main focus. If you wear most New Balance shoes in the rain, your feet will likely get wet.
Columbia Water Technology
Water protection is one of Columbia’s strengths. Many of their shoes use special waterproof technologies like Omni-Tech or OutDry. These keep water out while still allowing sweat to escape. Columbia makes many fully waterproof shoes that can handle rain, puddles, and even shallow streams.
Water Resistance Comparison
If you need shoes for rainy conditions or wet environments, Columbia has a clear advantage. Their outdoor focus means they put more emphasis on keeping your feet dry in all conditions. New Balance does offer some water-resistant options, but water protection is not their primary focus.
Sole Construction and Traction
New Balance Soles
New Balance uses rubber compounds designed for good grip on pavement, gym floors, and other flat surfaces. Their running shoe soles often have patterns that help with forward movement. The thickness and pattern depend on what the shoe is designed for – running, walking, or training.
Columbia Soles
Columbia shoe soles are made for outdoor traction. They use rubber compounds that grip well on dirt, rocks, and uneven terrain. Many have deep, multi-directional lugs (bumps on the bottom) that dig into soft ground for better stability. Their winter boots often have special rubber that grips on ice and snow.
Traction Comparison
For everyday use on regular surfaces, both brands provide good traction. For outdoor use, especially on trails, mud, or snow, Columbia soles typically provide much better grip. Think about where you’ll be walking most often when choosing between these brands.
Price Range
New Balance Pricing
New Balance shoes range from about $60 to $180, with most popular models costing $80-$130. Their pricing is middle-range for athletic shoes – not the cheapest, but not the most expensive either. They often have sales, and you can find older models at outlet stores for less.
Columbia Pricing
Columbia shoes typically cost between $70 and $200, with hiking boots at the higher end of that range. Their waterproof and insulated models cost more than basic shoes. Like New Balance, Columbia has sales seasonally, and you can sometimes find good deals at outdoor stores.
Value Comparison
Both brands offer good value for the price, but for different uses. New Balance provides good value for athletic and everyday shoes. Columbia provides good value for outdoor and all-weather shoes. Generally, you get what you pay for with both brands – more expensive models have better features and materials.
User Reviews and Ratings
What People Say About New Balance
| Model | Overall Rating | Comfort | Durability | Style | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| New Balance 574 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | $80-90 |
| New Balance Fresh Foam 1080 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | ⭐⭐⭐☆☆ | $150-160 |
| New Balance 990 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | ⭐⭐⭐⭐☆ | $175-185 |
User comments: “I love how comfortable my New Balance shoes are right away!” “Great for my wide feet.” “I can wear them all day at school without any pain.” “The colors are cool and they go with everything I wear.”
What People Say About Columbia
| Model | Overall Rating | Comfort | Durability | Style | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Columbia Newton Ridge | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ | $90-100 |
| Columbia Redmond | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | $80-90 |
| Columbia Bugaboot | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ | $140-150 |
User comments: “My feet stay dry even in the rain!” “These shoes last forever.” “Great for hiking with my family.” “They needed some breaking in but now they’re super comfortable.”
Pros and Cons
New Balance Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Comes in many widths for all foot shapes | Not very waterproof for rainy days |
| Lightweight for easy running and playing | Not the best for hiking on rough trails |
| Very comfortable right from the first wear | May wear out faster in tough conditions |
| Great for sports and gym class | Not as warm for cold weather |
| Lots of cool colors and styles | Can get dirty easily |
| Good choices for kids with growing feet | Not as good grip on mud and trails |
| Bouncy cushioning that feels soft | Less protection from rocks and sticks |
| Easy to find in most shoe stores | Some models can be expensive |
Columbia Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Keeps feet dry in rain and puddles | Usually heavier than New Balance |
| Very tough and lasts a long time | Might need time to “break in” before feeling comfy |
| Great grip on slippery trails | Fewer width options for wide or narrow feet |
| Good protection from rocks and sticks | Not as light for running fast |
| Warm options for cold weather | Not as many bright colors or cool styles |
| Excellent for outdoor adventures | Can feel hot on very warm days |
| Strong soles that don’t wear out easily | Harder to find in regular shoe stores |
| Good ankle support for uneven ground | Often more expensive |
Conclusion
After looking at all these features, which brand should you choose? It really depends on what you need shoes for:
New Balance might be better for you if:
- You need shoes for sports, running, or gym class
- You have wide or narrow feet and need special width options
- You want lighter shoes that feel comfortable right away
- You’re looking for trendy styles for everyday wear
- You mostly walk on normal surfaces like sidewalks and hallways
Columbia might be better for you if:
- You need shoes for hiking, camping, or outdoor activities
- You want waterproof shoes that keep your feet dry in rain or puddles
- You need good traction on trails, mud, or slippery surfaces
- You value durability and long-lasting shoes
- You live somewhere with lots of rain or snow
Both New Balance and Columbia make quality shoes that many people love. The most important thing is finding shoes that fit your feet well and work for the activities you do most. If possible, try on both brands to see which feels better on your feet. Remember, the best shoes are the ones that keep your feet comfortable and healthy!
Frequently Asked Questions
Which brand is better for hiking trails – New Balance or Columbia?
Columbia excels in outdoor terrain with specialized traction and weather protection, while New Balance offers limited trail options.
Are Columbia shoes more durable than New Balance?
Columbia shoes typically offer superior durability for outdoor conditions, while New Balance focuses on athletic performance.
Which brand provides better everyday comfort?
New Balance is generally preferred for daily urban wear and walking comfort, with specialized cushioning technologies.
Do Columbia shoes offer better water resistance than New Balance
Yes, Columbia specializes in weather protection with many waterproof options, while New Balance has fewer water-resistant models.
Which brand is more stylish for casual wear?
New Balance has greater fashion appeal and street cred, while Columbia prioritizes function over trendy aesthetics.